Kerala Transport Minister CP John’s remarks on the state government’s Priyadarshini free bus travel scheme for women have triggered a political controversy, with the CPI(M) strongly criticising his comments and accusing him of making insensitive observations about women beneficiaries. The minister, however, defended his statement, saying his remarks were intended as self-criticism and not as an insult to women who use the welfare initiative. The controversy began after John’s speech at the Kerala Bus Transport Association (KBTA) conference in Palakkad, where he discussed the impact of the Priyadarshini free bus travel scheme and its popularity among women across the state.

The KBTA represents private bus owners and operators in Kerala. During his address, John said the large number of women choosing government-supported free bus services was a reflection of their financial circumstances rather than a rejection of private transport operators. “The reason people leave your buses and wait for Priyadarshini buses, pushing and jostling to board them, is not because they hate you or love me. It is because housewives in our state do not have money in their hands,” John said during the conference. He argued that the success of the scheme highlighted the economic challenges faced by many women and their need for affordable mobility options.

The minister also referred to Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, saying he had recognised the financial difficulties faced by women and supported free bus travel initiatives. John said welfare measures such as free public transport were introduced after understanding the economic realities of households, particularly the limited financial independence of many women. However, some of his other remarks sparked criticism. John questioned what he described as contradictory choices made by people while accessing public services. He said some women who struggle to pay bus fares still prefer private schools for their children even when government schools have available seats.

Also Read: V.D. Satheesan Requests Vijay's Intervention Over Kerala Construction Material Policy

He also pointed out that many families choose government hospitals for treatment because they cannot afford private healthcare. The comments led to criticism from the CPI(M), which accused the minister of making remarks that appeared to blame women for their choices rather than addressing wider social and economic issues. Political opponents argued that decisions regarding education, healthcare, and transport are often influenced by several factors, including quality of services, accessibility, and personal circumstances. Facing backlash, John defended his statement and said his words had been misinterpreted by the media and political opponents.

Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, he maintained that he stood by his comments and described them as an attempt at self-reflection by political leaders. He said politicians, including himself, should acknowledge the struggles faced by women and work towards better solutions. “I stand by what I said. It was a self-criticism. Rahul Gandhi understood the hardships faced by women here, but politicians, including me, failed to recognise them,” John said while responding to the criticism. He added that the remarks were not intended to suggest that women receiving benefits under the Priyadarshini scheme were accepting charity.

The Priyadarshini free bus travel scheme has been viewed by the Kerala government as a measure aimed at improving women’s mobility and reducing financial barriers to transportation. Such initiatives have become a significant part of welfare discussions in several states, with supporters highlighting their role in improving access to education, employment, and essential services. The controversy surrounding John’s remarks has once again brought attention to debates over welfare schemes, economic independence of women, and political messaging around government support programmes. While the minister insists that his comments were aimed at highlighting economic realities, critics continue to question the manner in which the issue was addressed.

Also Read: Kerala Introduces Price Shield Scheme Ahead Of Onam Festival Shopping