The Shubman Gill-captained Indian cricket team confronts a pivotal must-win scenario in the second One-Day International (ODI) against Australia at the Adelaide Oval on Thursday, October 23, 2025, following a disheartening seven-wicket defeat in the rain-shortened opener in Perth on October 19. Batting first in a 26-over match reduced by persistent showers, India crumbled to 136/9, with only KL Rahul (32) and Axar Patel (28*) offering resistance amid a top-order collapse that saw captain Gill (10), Rohit Sharma (8), Virat Kohli (0), and Shreyas Iyer (11) all perish cheaply.
Australia chased the target in just 20.3 overs, led by an unbeaten 58 from Mitchell Marsh, extending their historical ODI edge over India to 85 wins against 58, including a dominant 39-14 record on home soil. This three-match series, part of India's 2025 tour Down Under and a key preparatory phase for the 2027 ODI World Cup, underscores the urgency for tactical recalibration, particularly in the bowling department, where the absence of left-arm wrist-spinner Kuldeep Yadav drew sharp criticism from experts.
The first ODI exposed vulnerabilities in India's attack, which relied on three specialist pacers—Arshdeep Singh (1/28), Mohammed Siraj (1/32), and debutant Harshit Rana (0/27)—alongside all-rounders Nitish Kumar Reddy (0/16) and Washington Sundar (0/14), with Axar Patel chipping in economically (1/25). Kuldeep's omission, despite his stellar form—including 17 wickets in the Asia Cup 2025 triumph and a pivotal role in India's ICC Champions Trophy semi-final victory over Australia earlier this year—sparked debates on balancing batting depth against spin variety.
Former India pacer Varun Aaron advocated for his inclusion, arguing that India's robust top order negates the need for excessive lower-order batting, while ex-all-rounder Irfan Pathan suggested compromising depth to unleash Kuldeep's middle-over menace on Adelaide's batsman-friendly pitch. Kuldeep, with 181 ODI wickets at an average of 26.7, could exploit the venue's occasional turn, where spinners have historically claimed 25% of dismissals in recent matches, though pacers dominate overall. Weather forecasts predict hazy sunshine with temperatures between 11°C and 20°C, favouring a full 50-over contest and potentially aiding swing early on.
India's predicted playing XI reflects a likely shift toward spin reinforcement, with Kuldeep Yadav poised to reclaim his spot at the expense of either the 22-year-old Nitish Kumar Reddy or Harshit Rana, both of whom endured modest outings in Perth—Reddy scoring 19 runs without a wicket and Rana wicketless in a testing spell. Consensus from multiple previews suggests Rohit Sharma, Shubman Gill (c), Virat Kohli, Shreyas Iyer, Axar Patel, KL Rahul (wk), Nitish Kumar Reddy/Harshit Rana, Kuldeep Yadav, Arshdeep Singh, Mohammed Siraj, and Prasidh Krishna (replacing Rana for added pace bounce).
The top four—despite their collective failure—are expected to persist, aligning with India's trend of rebounding after series openers, as evidenced by Kohli's two ODI centuries at Adelaide (107 vs Pakistan in 2015 and 104 vs Australia in 2019). Rahul and Axar remain fixtures for their dual contributions, while Reddy's all-round utility might edge out Rana's raw pace if batting stability is prioritised. However, some outlets, like The Indian Express, foresee a more conservative lineup retaining Sundar for depth and Rana for seam options. Prasidh Krishna's potential recall, fresh from IPL 2025's leading wicket-taker honours and a match-winning spell in the Oval Test against England in August, could bolster the attack on the Adelaide Oval's true-bounce surface.
Also Read: No Bright Spots: Ashwin Tears Into India After ODI Loss to Australia
Australia, meanwhile, holds the series advantage and is tipped to field an unchanged XI from Perth: Mitchell Marsh (c), Travis Head, Marnus Labuschagne, Josh Inglis (wk), Mitchell Owen, Alex Carey, Cooper Connolly, Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc, Nathan Ellis, and Xavier Bartlett, with Carey reclaiming his spot from Josh Philippe. Marsh's all-round prowess—he scored a brisk 58* in the opener—poses a direct threat to India's seamers, while the hosts' pace battery, including Starc's express speeds, thrives at home.
Under head coach Gautam Gambhir, India grapples with the Kuldeep conundrum amid broader selection debates, including whispers around Rohit Sharma's future form and Gill's nascent captaincy. A victory here is imperative not just for series parity but to rebuild momentum in a rivalry defined by narrow margins—India's last Adelaide ODI win dates back to 2019. Broadcast live on Star Sports in India from 1:30 p.m. IST, the match promises high stakes and strategic intrigue at this iconic venue.
Also Read: Should India Pick Kuldeep Yadav For 2nd ODI vs Australia? Shubman Gill, Gambhir Sent Strong Selection Message