England batter Jamie Smith came under intense criticism from both English and Australian experts for a reckless dismissal on Day 2 of the fifth Ashes Test against Australia on January 5, 2026. After a strong start to the day, featuring a solid partnership between Joe Root and Harry Brook, England appeared to be gaining control of the match. Brook's wicket did not disrupt the momentum significantly, as Root found a reliable ally in Smith. The duo added 94 runs, putting England in a promising position before Smith's innings ended abruptly.

Smith was dismissed for 46 after playing an aggressive shot off part-time bowler Marnus Labuschagne, resulting in a catch in the deep. The shot was widely condemned as unnecessarily risky, especially given the context of the game. Former Australia coach Justin Langer described it in scathing terms during commentary, calling it "the dumbest shot ever" seen in Test cricket. He noted that Smith had earlier survived a soft dismissal off a no-ball from Cameron Green, adding to the frustration over his decision to attack in that manner.

Former England captain Nasser Hussain echoed the sentiment, labeling the dismissal as one of the worst of the series for England. He highlighted the poor timing of the shot, pointing out that it occurred just nine minutes before lunch and only five overs before the new ball would be available. Hussain stressed that Smith could have simply survived the remaining time and rebuilt after the break, criticizing the inability of the current England side to adapt to the match situation despite their evident talent.

Also Read: Ben Stokes, Jofra Archer Clash During Ashes Test Amid Tactical Breakdown

The incident underscored ongoing debates about England's aggressive "Bazball" approach in Test cricket, where positive intent is prioritized but sometimes leads to avoidable collapses. With the Ashes series reaching its decisive phase, Smith's dismissal handed Australia renewed momentum heading into the latter stages of the match. The criticism from both sides of the commentary box reflected the high stakes and expectations surrounding individual performances in this historic rivalry.

As the Test continues, England will need to regroup quickly to counter Australia's bowling attack and capitalize on the foundation laid by Root and others. The series has already produced dramatic moments, and this latest controversy around Smith's shot selection adds another layer of intensity to the contest. Fans and analysts alike will watch closely to see how England responds in the coming days.

Also Read: All Eyes on Shubman Gill as Punjab Face Goa in Vijay Hazare Trophy Match