The title of London’s oldest riverside pub remains a fiercely contested yet unresolved debate between two East End gems: the Mayflower and the Prospect of Whitby. Both claim the crown, proudly displaying signs proclaiming their status, but historical complexities and a lack of official certification leave the question open, fueling a “loving rivalry” that captivates locals and tourists alike.
The Prospect of Whitby, located in Wapping on the Thames’ northern bank, asserts it was established in 1520, originally as The Pelican, later dubbed the Devil’s Tavern for its notorious clientele of smugglers, pirates, and thieves. Its 400-year-old flagstone floor, surviving a 1666 arson attack, and a pewter-topped bar—the longest in Britain—are tangible links to its past. Historical records, including John Stow’s accounts, note it as a hangout for river criminals, with “Hanging Judge Jeffreys” allegedly watching executions at nearby Execution Dock. Notable visitors, from Samuel Pepys to Charles Dickens, add to its lore. However, a significant fire in the early 19th century led to a rebuild, and the current structure, named after a Tyne collier ship, dates to 1774, when a retired captain reinforced it with ship timbers. Assistant manager Justin Billington insists on continuous operation, citing locals drinking from a surviving beer barrel the day after the 1666 fire, but skeptics argue the 1774 reconstruction resets its claim.
The Mayflower, across the Thames in Rotherhithe, ties its history to the 1620 voyage of the Pilgrim ship Mayflower, which sailed from its site to America. While renamed in 1957, the pub claims roots in the 16th century, with some of the ship’s original timbers purportedly built into its structure. Pubgoers with proven descent from Mayflower passengers can sign its “Descendants Book,” a unique draw. Its website evokes a romanticized history, suggesting continuity since the Pilgrims’ era, but critics note the current building likely dates to the 18th century, with nearby pubs like the Angel (1830s) predating its present form. The Mayflower’s claim hinges on its site’s association with the 1620 voyage, yet lacks concrete evidence of uninterrupted operation as a pub since then.
Also Read: Shivaji Maharaj’s Forts Just Made UNESCO History – You Won’t Believe Which Ones!
Both pubs, steeped in history, offer a step back in time with dark-paneled walls, nautical relics, and Thames views, serving classics like steak and ale pie. The Prospect boasts a grisly noose outside, ghost stories, and visits from artists like J.M.W. Turner, while the Mayflower’s cozy “olde-worlde” charm draws crowds despite doubts about its age. Londoner Emily Godwin, sipping a pint at the Prospect, told AP, “It feels like you’re drinking with pirates or Dickens characters,” capturing their timeless allure.
The debate is muddied by historical ambiguities. Pubs often changed names, faced rebuilds, or shifted locations, complicating claims. English historian Jacob Field notes that unlike the Porch House in Gloucestershire, dubbed England’s oldest pub from the 10th century, London lacks an official arbiter for such titles. Guinness World Records avoids certifying London’s oldest pub due to these challenges. If the Prospect’s 1520 origin holds, it predates the Mayflower’s 16th-century claim, but the latter’s defenders argue its Pilgrim connection and earlier site activity give it precedence. Conversely, the Prospect’s 1774 rebuild could tilt the scales toward the Mayflower if continuity is questioned.
With no definitive records, the rivalry remains unresolved, enriched by both pubs’ vibrant histories. The Prospect’s Grade II-listed status (1950) and tales of Princess Margaret’s visits contrast with the Mayflower’s quieter, yet evocative, Pilgrim legacy. As British pubs face closures—378 projected in 2025 per the British Beer and Pub Association—their competition underscores their cultural value. For now, visitors to these Thames-side haunts can savor the debate over a pint, choosing their champion in London’s storied pub saga.
Also Read: Nuns’ Arrest a Misunderstanding, Says BJP Chief