Winter brings not only shorter days and festive cheer but also a resurgence of longstanding health myths that influence behaviors from beverage choices to outdoor habits. Phrases like "Don't drink cold water—you'll catch a cold!" echo across generations, particularly from elders, and proliferate on social media. These beliefs often stem from anecdotal observations rather than empirical evidence, yet they persist despite advances in medical understanding.
In reality, the common cold—primarily caused by over 200 rhinoviruses and other pathogens like coronaviruses—affects the upper respiratory tract through viral infection, not environmental factors like temperature or chilled drinks. Winter sees a 20-30% increase in respiratory illnesses, per Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) data, but this correlates with behavioral and environmental shifts rather than cold itself. Indoor crowding, low humidity (often below 30% in heated homes), and reduced vitamin D from less sunlight impair mucosal barriers and immune responses, facilitating viral spread. Below, we dissect six prevalent myths with insights from peer-reviewed studies and expert consensus.
Myth 1: Drinking Cold Water Causes a Cold
This enduring belief posits that chilled water lowers body temperature, weakening immunity and inviting illness. Scientific scrutiny reveals no causal link.
Also Read: Is Fluoride Really Dangerous? Dentist Busts Viral Toothpaste Myths With Science-Backed Facts
Rhinoviruses require direct transmission via droplets or surfaces to infect nasal epithelia; cold liquids do not introduce or activate viruses. A 2015 study in Rhinology exposed participants to cold air and drinks, finding no increased infection rates compared to controls. Cold water might transiently constrict blood vessels or irritate pharyngeal tissues—exacerbating symptoms in those already infected—but it does not initiate disease. Harvard Medical School experts note that any perceived connection arises from confirmation bias, where post-exposure symptoms coincide with cold consumption.
Myth 2: Cold Weather Directly Causes More Colds
The spike in winter illnesses fuels the idea that low temperatures breed viruses or suppress immunity outright.
Viruses thrive at 33-35°C (91-95°F), the temperature inside the human nose, regardless of external cold, as shown in a 2013 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences study where mice cooled to 5°C below normal body temperature experienced 100-fold higher rhinovirus replication. However, humans aren't directly "caused" illness by weather; instead, factors like prolonged indoor gatherings (boosting aerosol transmission by up to 10 times, per MIT modeling) and dry air (reducing ciliary clearance in airways) dominate. A UK study in The Lancet (2016) across 45,000 households confirmed no direct temperature-illness correlation after controlling for behavior.
Myth 3: You Don't Need Much Water in Winter
Thirst diminishes in cold months due to lower sweat rates, leading many to skimp on fluids— a risky oversight.
Dehydration thickens mucus, impairing its trap-and-expel function against pathogens; a 2020 Journal of Nutrition review linked even mild dehydration (1-2% body weight loss) to 25% reduced immune cell efficiency. Winter heating drops indoor humidity to 10-20%, accelerating fluid loss via respiration (up to 1 liter daily unnoticed). The European Food Safety Authority recommends 2-2.5 liters daily for adults, from any temperature source—cold water hydrates equally effectively, though warm fluids may soothe irritation.
Myth 4: Vitamin C Prevents Colds
Promoted since Linus Pauling's 1970s advocacy, high-dose vitamin C (e.g., 1-2g daily) is hailed as a winter shield.
A Cochrane meta-analysis of 29 trials (11,000+ participants) found no preventive effect in the general population, with at most a 5-8% symptom duration reduction in marathon runners or soldiers under stress. It supports collagen synthesis and antioxidant defenses but doesn't halt viral entry. Sources like citrus outperform supplements due to bioavailability synergies with flavonoids.
Myth 5: Alcohol Keeps You Warm
The rosy glow after a hot toddy feels warming, but physiology tells a different story.
Ethanol vasodilates peripheral vessels, increasing skin blood flow and convective heat loss—dropping core temperature by 0.3-0.5°C per standard drink, per a New England Journal of Medicine study. It also impairs shivering thermogenesis. The CDC warns it heightens hypothermia risk in cold exposure, contrary to folklore.
Myth 6: Allergies Disappear in Winter
Many dismiss winter sniffles as colds, ignoring year-round allergens.
Indoor humidity fosters dust mites (peaking at 70-80% RH) and mold in poorly ventilated homes, per Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology data showing 20% of "winter colds" as allergic rhinitis. Symptoms overlap—congestion, itchy eyes—but antihistamines resolve allergies, unlike antivirals for viruses.
In conclusion, viruses—not temperatures or drinks—drive colds. Prioritize hand hygiene (reducing transmission by 16-21%, per WHO), ventilation, and 7-9 hours sleep to bolster defenses. Dispelling these myths empowers evidence-based wellness.
Also Read: Chest Feels Heavy This Winter? Doctor Reveals It May Not Be Just Cold Air