Supreme Court Oversight Leaves ISL Season Hanging With No Bidders

Seven months after Mohun Bagan Super Giant clinched the Indian Super League (ISL) title, Indian football remains mired in one of its darkest chapters, with the Supreme Court emerging as the unlikely epicenter of activity rather than the pitch. The All India Football Federation (AIFF) has turned back to the apex court following a failed bidding process for the league's commercial rights, which drew zero submissions despite an extension of the deadline from November 5 to November 7, 2025. The tender, floated on October 16 under the oversight of retired Justice L. Nageswara Rao's Bid Evaluation Committee and managed by KPMG, sought a partner for a 15-year deal covering broadcasting, sponsorship, digital, and merchandising rights, with a minimum annual guarantee of ₹37.5 crore or 5% of gross revenue. This impasse, rooted in the Supreme Court's September 19 directive to adopt a new AIFF constitution emphasizing federation ownership and promotion-relegation from 2025-26, has stalled the 12th ISL season indefinitely, leaving clubs like the champions to suspend first-team operations and review player contracts amid financial uncertainty.

The absence of bids from four pre-bid attendees—including Football Sports Development Limited (FSDL), FanCode, Conscient Heritage Group, and an overseas consortium—stems from concerns over revenue sharing, financial risks, and limited commercial partner influence in the revamped league council, which allocates just one of six seats to the rights holder under the court-approved constitution. Litigants had pushed for this overhaul to reclaim the league from what they viewed as an undervalued private handover, but the fallout risks a distress sale of rights and exposes structural flaws, including the federation's sole ownership model that deters investors seeking stability. While the AIFF, despite its president's role on the evaluation panel, bears little blame for the lack of interest, it now shoulders the burden of resolution, with the committee set to submit a report to the Supreme Court imminently for guidance on next steps. Players and staff, amplifying their plight on social media without assigning direct fault, underscore the human cost: unpaid wages, disrupted training, and an existential limbo that extends beyond the ISL to the federation-run I-League, where operations may prove untenable without a commercial backer.

In a rare glimmer amid the gloom, ISL clubs and players have rallied behind the AIFF in urging the Supreme Court to expedite the league's launch, with reports indicating an independent petition from club CEOs to break the deadlock. This unified front highlights a fragile consensus in a sport long plagued by administrative infighting, echoing the 2021 court intervention that ousted former AIFF chief Praful Patel amid FIFA suspension threats. Yet, the silence on I-League woes—where clubs face parallel shutdowns—reveals deeper inequities, as the second tier's lack of sponsorship amplifies the crisis for non-elite stakeholders. As argumentative voices debate governance ideals, from open promotion to equitable revenue models, the federation's plea could prompt constitutional tweaks, potentially salvaging the season but at the cost of further eroding on-field momentum in a nation aspiring to Asian football relevance.

Also Read: Sudharsan Dropped for 1st Test as India Opts for Bowling-Heavy Line-up

A tentative beacon of hope pierces through with the national team's camp, where Australian-born forward Ryan Williams has joined preparations for the AFC Asian Cup qualifier against Bangladesh on November 18 in Dhaka, marking his debut eligibility after surrendering his passport for Indian citizenship. The 31-year-old Bengaluru FC striker, whose maternal lineage traces to India via his Mumbai-born mother and grandfather Lincoln Grostate—a 1950s Western India Football Association player—brings proven finishing prowess, having once represented Australia in a friendly and credited by retiring icon Sunil Chhetri for easing defensive pressure during Bengaluru's strong 2024-25 ISL campaign. Under interim coach Khalid Jamil, Williams could mentor emerging forwards like Irfan Yadwad, Mohammed Sanan, Vikram Partap Singh, and Rahim Ali, addressing India's long-standing need for a reliable No. 9 in a squad eyeing a morale-boosting win to cap its faltering qualifying campaign before a March home clash with Hong Kong.

Also Read: Portugal Need Just One Result to Book Their FIFA World Cup 2026 Ticket