Sudharsan Dropped for 1st Test as India Opts for Bowling-Heavy Line-up

The Indian cricket team's controversial decision to drop promising batsman Sai Sudharsan from the playing XI for the first Test against South Africa at Eden Gardens has ignited a firestorm of criticism from former players and fans alike, with ex-India all-rounder Dodda Ganesh labelling it "no sense whatsoever". Despite Sudharsan's recent form, including scores of 87 and 39 in his debut Test series against England earlier in 2025, the 23-year-old left-hander was overlooked in favour of a spin-heavy lineup featuring four slow bowlers and three all-rounders, prompting questions about the team's batting stability on a pitch expected to assist turn from day three onwards. Captain Shubman Gill, in his pre-match comments at the toss—where South Africa elected to bat first—sidestepped queries on the omission, focusing instead on the surface's potential for early seam movement and the squad's collective hunger, while confirming Rishabh Pant's return in place of Nitish Kumar Reddy and Axar Patel's inclusion over Sudharsan. This move has fuelled debates on social media, where supporters decry the apparent lack of faith in Sudharsan as the long-term successor to Cheteshwar Pujara at number three, a slot now tentatively assigned to bowling all-rounder Washington Sundar.

Sudharsan, a product of the Gujarat Titans setup in the IPL and a domestic standout with over 3,000 first-class runs at an average above 50, earned his Test cap earlier this year amid India's transitional phase post-Rohit Sharma's retirement from the format. His exclusion, just months after a debut hundred against England at Lord's, mirrors a pattern of high-profile drops for young talents, including predecessors like Prithvi Shaw and Shubman Gill himself in earlier cycles, but comes at a precarious time for India's middle order, which has relied on his technical solidity against spin. The playing XI—Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul, Washington Sundar, Shubman Gill (c), Rishabh Pant (wk), Dhruv Jurel, Ravindra Jadeja, Axar Patel, Kuldeep Yadav, Jasprit Bumrah, and Mohammed Siraj—leans heavily on all-round utility, with two specialist keepers in Pant and Jurel signalling a batting depth bolstered by lower-order contributions. Critics, including former leg-spinner Anil Kumble, expressed surprise at the "fascination with all-rounders", arguing it undermines specialist batsmen like Sudharsan, who could have anchored the innings on a dry Kolkata track prepared for the World Test Championship cycle.

Dodda Ganesh, a 2003 World Cup squad member known for his candid takes, amplified the backlash on X, questioning the logic of benching Sudharsan for a fourth spinner when the number three position demands a "vision" rather than "musical chairs". "Can't believe this is happening at the Test level," Ganesh posted, echoing sentiments from fans who point to Sudharsan's adaptability—evident in his Ranji Trophy exploits and a gritty 96 against South Africa A last month—as reason enough for continuity. Social media erupted with comparisons to past selection gaffes, such as the premature axing of Karun Nair after a triple tonne, while some attributed the call to head coach Gautam Gambhir's tactical blueprint, which prioritises balance over batting firepower in subcontinental conditions. The debate has overshadowed the series opener, part of India's bid to reclaim home supremacy after a 1-1 draw in Pakistan, against a South African side missing pace spearhead Kagiso Rabada but bolstered by spinners Keshav Maharaj and Simon Harmer.

Also Read: South Africa Seek Rare Survival in India: Here’s How to Watch the 1st Test Live

As the match unfolds with South Africa at 31/0 after seven overs—thanks to Aiden Markram's fluent boundaries off Siraj—the spotlight intensifies on Gill's leadership in his first full Test series as captain, sans Rohit and Virat Kohli's guiding presence. Sudharsan's demotion to the bench, alongside Devdutt Padikkal and Akash Deep, raises broader concerns about youth integration in a format grappling for relevance amid T20's dominance, potentially stunting the next generation's growth if not addressed in the second Test at New Wankhede Stadium. For now, the Eden Gardens crowd—braving Kolkata's winter chill—watches a bowler-rich India chase quick breakthroughs, but the real test may lie in reconciling selection gambles with long-term vision to sustain the five-day game's legacy in the subcontinent.

Also Read: IPL 2026: Shardul Thakur Joins Mumbai Indians as Arjun Tendulkar Moves to Lucknow