Manika Batra Challenges Selection Process After Asian Games Snub, Writes to PM Modi
Manika Batra questions Asian Games selection process, writes PM.
India’s table tennis star Manika Batra has formally raised concerns over her exclusion from the national squad for the upcoming Asian Games, writing to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya. In her communication, she has questioned the consistency and fairness of the selection process followed by the Table Tennis Federation of India (TTFI), triggering renewed debate on national team selection norms. Batra, one of India’s most accomplished and internationally recognised table tennis players, was left out of the main squad after failing to meet the selection criteria linked to participation in domestic ranking tournaments.
Her absence from these events meant she did not feature in the TTFI’s ranking list, which is a key parameter used for final team selection. The 31-year-old athlete has argued that the selection framework does not adequately account for international performance and experience, particularly in cases involving established players who regularly represent India on global platforms. Her exclusion has been viewed as significant given her long-standing contribution to Indian table tennis and her status as one of the sport’s most visible figures.
According to the existing selection policy, participation in designated domestic competitions is mandatory for ranking consideration. Players who do not compete in these events are excluded from the official list used to determine eligibility for major tournaments. Based on this system, Batra was placed among the reserves rather than the core squad, alongside Swastika Ghosh. In her letter to the Prime Minister and the Sports Minister, Batra has reportedly called for a review of the selection process, seeking greater transparency, consistency, and alignment between domestic ranking structures and international performance standards.
Also Read: Neeraj Chopra Returns to Competitive Action After Nine Months at Doha Diamond League
Her appeal highlights concerns that rigid adherence to domestic participation rules may disadvantage top-performing athletes who are engaged in international circuits. The development has drawn attention within India’s sporting ecosystem, where selection controversies have periodically emerged across disciplines. Critics of the current system argue that over-reliance on domestic rankings can sometimes fail to reflect the true competitive standing of elite athletes, especially those with established international credentials. Supporters of the existing framework, however, maintain that domestic participation ensures fairness, accountability, and equal opportunity for all players vying for national selection.
They argue that consistent involvement in national tournaments is necessary to maintain competitive balance and transparency in team selection. Batra’s omission has also raised broader questions about how India balances the demands of domestic sporting structures with the realities of international competition schedules. With Indian athletes increasingly participating in global events, scheduling conflicts and selection eligibility criteria have become recurring points of contention. The issue is expected to prompt further discussion within sporting authorities, particularly regarding potential reforms to selection guidelines for major multi-sport events such as the Asian Games. For now, Batra remains part of the reserves, while the final squad selection continues to be a subject of scrutiny and debate within the table tennis community.
Also Read: Ben Stokes Set to Return for England's New Zealand Finale After Curfew Breach Suspension
