Trump-Putin Summit in Alaska Stirs Controversy

As US President Donald Trump prepares to meet Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska on Friday, August 15, the choice of venue highlights the state’s deep historical ties with Russia and its strategic significance, while sparking debate over its symbolic implications. The summit, aimed at addressing the Russia-Ukraine war, marks the first meeting between the two leaders since 2019 and the first on US soil since 1988, set against Alaska’s unique past as a former Russian territory.

Alaska’s connection to Russia began in the 18th century when Siberian fur traders established settlements in Sitka and Kodiak Island, exploiting Alaska Natives to harvest sea otter pelts, according to University of Alaska Anchorage history professor Ian Hartman. By 1867, with resources depleted and Russia weakened from the Crimean War, Czar Alexander II sold Alaska to the US for $7.2 million, a deal dubbed “Seward’s Folly” until gold discoveries in 1896 proved its value. Today, Russian Orthodox churches and surnames among Alaska Natives reflect this legacy, with Little Diomede Island just 5 kilometers from Russia’s Big Diomede.

Alaska’s strategic role grew during World War II, when Japanese forces captured Attu Island, leading to the “forgotten battle” of 1943. During the Cold War, fears of Soviet attacks via Alaska prompted the US to build radar and missile defense systems, shaping much of the state’s infrastructure, including roads and the trans-Alaska pipeline. In 2024, the Pentagon deployed 130 soldiers to the Aleutians amid increased Russian military activity, underscoring Alaska’s ongoing geopolitical importance.

Also Read: PM Modi to Address UNGA Amid US Trade Tensions

The state has hosted global leaders before, including Japanese Emperor Hirohito in 1971, President Ronald Reagan and Pope John Paul II in 1984, and Chinese President Xi Jinping in 2017. However, Putin’s visit, the first by a Russian leader, has drawn criticism. The Anchorage Assembly severed its sister-city tie with Magadan, Russia, in 2022, and Juneau expressed concerns to Vladivostok, reflecting strained sentiments post-Ukraine invasion. Protests by Stand Up Alaska are planned for Thursday and Friday.

Critics, including former British Ambassador Nigel Gould-Davies, argue that Alaska’s history as a transferred territory sends a dangerous message, potentially implying to Putin that “territories can change hands,” especially amid Ukraine talks. Dimitry Shein, a Soviet émigré to Anchorage, voiced concerns over Trump’s authoritarian leanings, noting similarities between US and Russian political climates. Despite the controversy, Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy welcomed the summit, calling the state a “strategic crossroads” for diplomacy.

Also Read: Trial Weighs Trump’s Use of Troops in Los Angeles