Congress Faces Internal Crisis As SC Ministers Split On Quota
Party leadership weighs options as SC ministers disagree on quota policy.
The Indian National Congress government in Karnataka is facing a political dilemma over whether to implement internal reservation quotas for Scheduled Caste (SC) communities as it prepares for a crucial cabinet meeting — exposing deep divisions among SC ministers and complicating efforts to fill thousands of government jobs. The debate highlights persistent complexities in India’s reservation politics and comes as the state moves to recruit tens of thousands of candidates in one of its largest recruitment drives.
At the centre of the dispute is the government’s plan to fill 56,432 government posts under the existing 50 % reservation cap, with 15 % allocated to SCs. While the Governor has already given assent to the controversial Karnataka Scheduled Castes Sub-Classification Bill, 2025 — which proposes internal quotas within the SC quota — legal challenges and Supreme Court limits have led officials to proceed cautiously by reverting to the older 15 % base for this recruitment cycle.
SC ministers are sharply split over whether to implement internal reservation within that 15 % during the current recruitment process. Some ministers representing the SC Left communities argue that there is no legal obstacle to proportionately dividing the SC quota internally at this stage, citing clarifications from the Advocate General that such a move is feasible without breaching legal ceilings.
Also Read: Congress Criticizes Curriculum Revisions, Flags RSS Role In NCERT Row
However, ministers from other SC sub-groups are less enthusiastic about adjusting the quota this way before the court’s final decision on the 17 % reservation proposal — a formula that would divide SC sub-groups as recommended by the Justice HN Nagamohan Das Commission. That commission’s original proposal suggested allocations that now exceed the Supreme Court’s 50 % overall cap, which has forced the government back to the more limited scheme for the time being.
The disagreement has placed Congress leaders in a political Catch-22: proceed with internal quota now and risk legal backlash or delay implementation and risk alienating significant sections of the SC electorate that have fought for such measures for decades. The rift was underscored by separate meetings between SC ministers and party leadership to press divergent positions ahead of the cabinet deliberations.
With the cabinet set to meet on March 5, 2026, the party leadership is under pressure to find a compromise that satisfies internal stakeholders while remaining within legal bounds. Failure to reach a resolution could have political ramifications beyond the reservation debate, affecting Congress’s support among Dalit communities in upcoming local and assembly elections.
Also Read: Opposition Hits Out At PM Modi Over PTI Interview, Calls It Scripted
