West Bengal Makes Vande Mataram Mandatory in Madrasas; AIMPLB Cites Fundamental Rights Violation

A fresh political and constitutional debate has emerged in West Bengal after Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari made the singing of Vande Mataram mandatory in all schools and madrasas across the state. The decision, announced shortly after the formation of the new government, requires students to sing the full national song during morning assemblies. While the state administration has described the move as an effort to promote patriotism and national unity, it has drawn criticism from several groups, including the All India Muslim Personal Law Board, which argues that the directive could conflict with the religious beliefs of some students.

The AIMPLB has formally opposed the notification and called for its immediate withdrawal. In a statement, the board's spokesperson, Dr. S.Q.R. Ilyas, said compelling students to recite a song against their religious convictions would violate fundamental constitutional rights. The organization has alternatively sought an exemption for Muslim students if the government chooses to retain the policy. The issue has reignited a long-standing national discussion about the balance between cultural traditions, patriotic practices, and individual religious freedoms in educational institutions.

Defending the government's decision, Adhikari maintained that respect for national symbols and observance of national occasions are essential civic responsibilities. He stated that singing Vande Mataram and the national anthem, Jana Gana Mana, should be mandatory for all citizens. The chief minister described the policy as part of India's cultural heritage and argued that schools play a crucial role in instilling national values among young people. His remarks have received support from sections of the ruling establishment and several political leaders who view the move as a reaffirmation of national identity.

Also Read: North Korea Reacts To US Military Commander’s Comments On South Korea And China Strategy

Among those backing the decision is Kiren Rijiju, who said Vande Mataram belongs to the entire nation and should not be viewed through a religious or political lens. Rijiju emphasized that the song is a national symbol rather than a representation of any particular community. Supporters of the policy argue that participation in the national song promotes unity and shared citizenship, while critics contend that compulsory participation could undermine constitutional protections related to freedom of conscience and belief.

The controversy comes amid broader national discussions surrounding the use of Vande Mataram at public functions. Recently, Shashi Tharoor questioned the requirement to play all verses of the national song at official events, calling the practice unnecessary. Tharoor clarified that he respects the song and its historical significance but argued that making the complete version mandatory at the beginning and end of functions could be burdensome. His comments drew criticism from political opponents, including leaders of the state BJP, who accused the Congress of weakening nationalist traditions.

Written by Bankim Chandra Chatterjee in the 1870s, Vande Mataram was accorded the status of India's national song by the Constituent Assembly in 1950. Earlier this year, the union government also issued directions regarding its performance at official events and educational institutions. As debate over the West Bengal directive continues, legal experts, political parties, and civil society groups are expected to closely examine the constitutional implications of compulsory participation, ensuring that the issue remains at the center of public discussion in the coming weeks.

Also Read: Srinagar Airport Scheduled For Twice-Weekly Flight Suspensions And Temporary Closure